Reese’s Crust Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe (2024)

by Heather 20 Comments

Reese’s Crust Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe

I am a self admitted chocoholic. Dark, milk, mint, white… any way you present it I adore it. When you combine it with peanut butter… o. m. geeeeeeee. BEYOND good! Reese’s peanut butter cups are adorning the shelves for Easter and I figured what better way to eat them with more peanut butter, right?Fudge with a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup “crust” makes my mouth immediately start watering.

These would make a great after school snack, a yummy Easter goodie or just because.

4.6 from 8 reviews

Reese's Crust Peanut Butter Fudge Recipe

Author: Heather

Ingredients

Reese's of any size,
3 Cups Granulated Sugar
1.5 Sticks of real unsalted butter
5 oz. Evaporated Milk
2 cups of Reese's Peanut Butter Chips
1- 7 oz jar of marshmallow cream (optional)

Instructions

I used a 12x8 Pan, but you can use any thing you want. A 9x13 tends to be too big.
Line the pan with Wax paper and Spray with cooking oil.
Using Reese's of any size, put one layer over the wax paper.
Prepare fudge using Granulated Sugar, butter and Evaporated Milk ;
(Put these three ingredients into the microwave for 2 minutes. Remove and mix,
put back into the microwave for 4 minutes, Remove and mix. Once more in the microwave for 1 minute).
Add: 2 cups of Reese's Peanut Butter Chips and mix until all chips are melted. Pour over prepared pan with Reese's Cups.
Put the fudge in the refrigerator until completely cooled and set.
**For a softer Fudge** After adding the Reese's PB chips and mixing until melted, add 1- 7 oz jar of marshmallow cream, mix well. Pour over prepared pan of Reese's cups.

About Heather

Heather, the mom behind OurKidsMom, is located in western Missouri. She is 3rd grade teacher turned stay at home mom with 4 children: Ethan (9), Emma (10), Joshua (20) and Kaytlin (25). She spends her "free time" at the gym, planning her next travel adventure, blogging, browsing Pinterest for her next craft and reviewing great products for her family and home.

Be sure to check out all posts by Heather and subscribe via RSS or EMAIL so you don't miss a thing!

Comments

Linda Meyers-Gabbardsays
at
This sounds so yummy. I want some. Thanks for sharing.
Reply
RICHARD HICKSsays
at
Reeses is my favorite candy of all. These look SO delicious. I want to give them a go.
Reply
Dorothy Bouchersays
at
OMG this looks sooooooooooooo delicious yummy 😉 heehe I think there is nothing better than having chocolate with peanut butter, one of my favorites 🙂 Yummy recipe and thanks for share @tisonlyme143
Reply
Julie Woodsays
at
I like fudge of any kind, and this fudge looks so delicious and a really good one to make for my family. We would all love this fudge because it has Reeses in it!!
Reply
Melissasays
at
I love reese peanut butter cups, but this recipe takes the cake! looks and sounds so good. I’m going to have to try to make them. =)
Reply
Jo-Ann Brightmansays
at
This recipe would be heaven for those people who love Reese’s peanut butter cups or just peanut butter . My older son is one of those people although he would probably like a chocolate layer on top.
Reply
Shannonsays
at
OMG these look so good. Thank you for sharing.
Reply
Jo-Ann Brightmansays
at
Wow this would really satisfy any craving for Reese’s cups. There is so much peanut butter flavor in here mixed with chocolate and so creamy. Yummy
Reply
Katesays
at
This sounds scrumptious! Definitely going to have to try it sometime!
Reply
Birdiebeesays
at
This recipe looks wonderful as well as easy. Thank you!
Reply
Elenasays
at
Looks so yummy! Thank you for the recipe
Reply
Shannonsays
at
OMG this looks so yummy! Thank you for sharing your recipe.
Reply
Terri Ssays
at
WOW! This sounds soooo good! I will be making them for this weekend! Thank you for sharing the recipe!
Reply
Dandi Dsays
at
This looks so amazing. Peanut butter is my favorite food ever!
Reply
Amy Orvinsays
at
Oh My! This recipe looks so amazing! It would be great to make for Easter.
Reply
nicole dziedzicsays
at
Peanut butter fudge is my favorite of them all, this is the perfect recipe for it too. Going to make this next week.
Reply
Barbara Riffesays
at
WOW, love this. 1000 calories I bet.
Reply
Danielle Royalegacysays
at
I need these! Gotta make them.
Reply
Sandra Wattssays
at
My mouth is watering looking that these and I think I even gained a pound but I would love to try them.
Reply
G Ksays
at
Peanut Butter Cups are my favorite candy! I so wish I could make these right now.
Reply